A quiet neighborhood pond bordered by green lawns, established trees and pale gabled homes in northeast Florida.

In SilverLeaf, Compare Every Resale With the Builder Deals Down the Street

November 19, 2026

At 250 Silver Lily Way in Silver Landing, a move-in-ready Dream Finders Stonehurst I is listed at $579,990. The builder's page shows the old price of $610,113 next to it, marked "$30K off." That page describes Silver Landing as down to its "final opportunities," with one home available. A few streets away, someone selling a five-year-old house of about the same size has to set a price that holds up against that $30,000 markdown and the builder's discounted mortgage rate.

That is the key pricing fact in SilverLeaf this winter. A resale here competes less with other resales and more with whatever the builders are running that month. If you're comparing SilverLeaf with other St. Johns County master-planned communities, judge each resale against the builder's price after incentives. Then decide what the established parts of the community are worth to you.

The competition is a year-end sale

Few communities on the First Coast have as many builders selling at once as SilverLeaf. Here is what their own pages showed in mid-November 2026.

Builder SilverLeaf section Advertised price Advertised incentive
Lennar Silver Meadows $404,990 to $639,990 Black Friday event with up to $30,000 in price reductions and paid closing costs, terms vary by home
Lennar Silver Falls single-family $424,990 to $664,480 Same Black Friday event
Lennar Silver Falls Townhomes Move-in-ready homes at $324,993 and $328,993 Same Black Friday event
Dream Finders Silver Landing From $519,990 $30,000 off a move-in-ready home, rates from 2.99% through its affiliated lender
Dream Finders Reverie at Silverleaf, 55+ From $331,990 Not listed on the community page
Taylor Morrison Cherry Elm townhomes Quick-move-in homes from $349,990 to $383,990 Recent price cuts of $5,000 to $10,000 on listed homes
David Weekley Evergreen Island Classic from $459,900, Executive from $466,900 Quick-move-in homes listed
ICI Homes Courtney Chase, Courtney Grove, Hidden Creek $502,900 up to $1,256,900 Not listed
Toll Brothers Newbrook $399,000 townhomes to $951,995 single-family Not listed
Mastercraft/Perry Homes 60, 70 and 80-foot homesites From the $870s to the $1 millions Year-End Sales Event and "Flex Cash Offer" on select 70-foot homes

Across these sections, prices run from the low $300,000s for townhomes to above $1.2 million for ICI's larger homes, so nearly any resale in SilverLeaf has a new-construction alternative near its price. Lennar alone lists 11 available homes in Silver Falls Single Family, with a sales office at 77 Superior Blvd.

Financing is part of the competition too. Dream Finders' Jacksonville sales event advertises rates "starting at 2.99%" with a 5.959% APR through Jet HomeLoans, and savings of up to $116,000 on selected move-in-ready homes across the region. Taylor Morrison's Jacksonville promotion, dated November 12 to 22, 2026, listed 4.875% FHA or 4.99% conventional financing on eligible quick-move-in homes closing by December 31, 2026. It also listed a base-price reduction of up to 8% for qualifying all-cash buyers in select communities. These offers change month to month and carry their own written terms. They are general information here, not financial advice, so confirm any rate or credit with your own lender before you rely on it.

Why the builder sets the price next door

Picture a buyer with a $560,000 budget. A resale in an established SilverLeaf village needs no construction wait. A new home in Silver Landing or Silver Meadows near the same price shows a discount already applied, and its builder advertises a promotional starting rate through an affiliated lender. The resale's asking price is being measured against that package.

That pressure shows up in the county numbers. In September 2026, a News4JAX report on St. Johns County resales said builder incentives, including rate buydowns, can make existing homes harder to sell. In the brokerage analysis it cited, 70.6% of St. Johns County owners who bought in 2022 or 2023 and had since sold did not recover their costs once an estimated 8% for buying and selling was counted. That figure covers homes that have already resold, not every owner. Still, it shows how much room a SilverLeaf resale seller who bought near the 2022 to 2023 peak may have to negotiate.

Builders are pulling back a little. Dream Finders, which is headquartered in Jacksonville, reported in its third-quarter 2026 results that companywide incentives as a share of homebuilding revenue were 56 basis points lower than a year earlier. That is a slight easing, and the year-end events above show discounts are still large in SilverLeaf right now.

The county numbers say buyers have time

The Northeast Florida Association of Realtors October 2026 report put the St. Johns County single-family median sale price at $564,449 for the month of October. It counted 1,470 active listings, 3.8 months of supply and a median of 49 days on market. In NEFAR's September 2026 report, the median was $568,750 and the median days on market was 42. From September to October, prices were roughly flat and homes took about a week longer to sell.

Over the year, the October 2026 median is about 1% above the $559,000 Florida Politics reported for October 2025. Prices are flat, homes are taking longer to sell, and there are close to four months of supply. A buyer in that market has time to compare a builder's net price with a resale owner's asking price before making an offer.

SilverLeaf's own resale activity tracks those county figures closely. In the 12 months through mid-November 2026, more than 500 SilverLeaf homes sold at a median a little above $540,000. Sellers who priced right got close to their final asking price in about six weeks.

Where a resale comes out ahead

The developer's site says SilverLeaf has "no CDD fees," and Dream Finders, Mastercraft and ICI say the same in their SilverLeaf marketing. HOA dues differ by village, so ask for each village's current figure when you compare a resale with a new home.

What a resale has that a new home lacks is a finished village around it. SilverLeaf's resident directory lists Brandon Lakes, Brook Forest, Elm Creek, Holly Forest, Johns Island, Newbrook, Silver Falls, Silver Landing, Silver Meadows, SilverLeaf Village and Waterford Lakes. A resale in one of the more established villages comes with grown landscaping, finished streets and neighbors who have already moved in. It also has no construction schedule. A resale in a section where builders are still selling competes with new homes head to head.

The amenities are already built. The community's amenity operator lists the main SilverLeaf Amenity Center, a Village Amenity Center with a pool pavilion, indoor room and event pavilion, and the Johns Island Amenity with two pool pavilions and a banquet room. Pools and tennis and pickleball courts are among the facilities. Mastercraft points buyers to a newer amenity center near its Hidden Creek and Courtney Oaks homes. Living close to a particular amenity center can matter as much as the house itself, and a resale lets you pick that location rather than take whatever lot a builder has left.

Daily services have filled in over 2026. The Publix at SilverLeaf Market, 1975 Silverleaf Parkway, opened March 26, and its liquor store opened the following week. In September, the Jacksonville Daily Record reported Avalon Nails and SoFresh open there, with Club Pilates, M Shack, My Tiffin and The UPS Store also coming to the center. Our earlier look at SilverLeaf Market's leasing follows that center in more detail. The Baptist & Wolfson Emergency Room at 8595 St. Johns Parkway opened September 22, 2026, according to the Jacksonville Daily Record. It treats adults and children and is on the same campus as Baptist outpatient services that opened in June. Magnolia Oaks Academy, a K–8 public school in SilverLeaf, opened for the 2026–27 school year.

What the newer sections are still waiting on

Several projects that will shape daily life in the newer parts of SilverLeaf are still under construction. St. Johns County is building the Silverleaf Sportsplex at Timberwolf Trail and County Road 16A, with turf and grass fields, a stadium field and track, and a playground. The county has forecast an early 2027 opening. Hutson Cos. and Skinner Bros. plan two SilverLeaf Corner Shoppes buildings totaling 16,100 square feet for restaurants and services. Construction was expected to start in the fourth quarter of 2026 and finish in the fourth quarter of 2027.

Roads are the other piece. The four-lane County Road 2209 segment from Silverleaf Parkway to International Golf Parkway opened October 28, 2025, according to St. Johns County. News4JAX reported in September that the State Road 16 widening from International Golf Parkway to just past CR 2209 was about 70% complete and expected to finish in early spring 2027. The First Coast Expressway segment from east of CR 2209 to east of CR 16A is listed by FDOT with a 2030 expected completion. If you are choosing a lot, its distance from SR 16 will affect your daily drive more over the next year than it will after that.

A few common questions

Should I wait for a bigger builder discount in SilverLeaf? Builder promotions follow the calendar. Lennar's current event is tied to Black Friday, and Taylor Morrison's offer required closing by December 31, 2026. Some sections, Silver Landing among them, are close to sold out. Waiting can mean fewer homes to choose from as well as a different discount.

Do townhomes face the same competition? Yes, at a lower price point. Lennar's Silver Falls Townhomes, Taylor Morrison's Cherry Elm and Toll Brothers' Newbrook townhomes all list homes between about $325,000 and $400,000, so a resale townhome in SilverLeaf is also priced against new ones. Our townhome versus single-family guide covers that choice in more detail.

If you're deciding between a SilverLeaf resale and a new home a few streets away, I can help you compare both on their real numbers: the builder's price after incentives, the resale's negotiating room, and the village and amenity center that come with each. Pamela Hoffman works with buyers comparing St. Johns County communities, and the new construction guide is a good place to start. Let's Talk About Your Move.

Work With Pamela

Pamela Hoffman is a top-performing real estate advisor and licensed broker associate who can expertly guide you through your real estate journey. With over 25 years of sales, leadership, and service experience, Pamela provides exceptional service while also making the real estate process fun.

Follow Me On Instagram